Dear Uncle Steve, Nine Years for Tarik Skubal Is a $400 Million Mistake

FLUSHING, NY – Here’s my open letter to Uncle Steve Cohen re the king’s ransom being thrown at a 30-year old pitcher with a history of arm injuries.

Dear Uncle Steve,

I’ve spent enough summers begging the Mets to spend money that it feels downright unnatural to ask you to put the checkbook away. But former Mets GM Jim Duquette (who made some dumb moves himself) reports that our Metsies offered Tarik Skubal nine years and nearly $400 million. Nine years should be the deal-breaker. www.mlb.com

Skubal just turned 30. He’s won two Cy Young Awards, and I’d love to see him take the ball on Opening Day at Citi Field. I’d also like somebody in that meeting to ask who takes the ball when he can’t. He had Tommy John surgery in college, flexor tendon surgery in 2022 that cost him 11 months, and another procedure this year to remove a loose body from his pitching elbow. If I’m the Mets, I’m pricing this deal as though another arm surgery is a matter of when. Nine years is an awfully long time to bet on the best-case scenario. www.reuters.com

Ask the Rangers. They gave Jacob deGrom five years and $185 million. Six starts into his first season in Texas, he needed Tommy John surgery. Gerrit Cole lost all of 2025 to Tommy John surgery during his nine-year Yankees deal. Carlos Rodón missed 100 games in his first season in the Bronx. And if you want an example of a guy who kept taking the ball, Patrick Corbin made 170 starts over six years in Washington. He finished the deal with a 5.62 ERA in his final season. You’re betting on two things here. First, that Skubal can take the ball. Second, that he’ll still pitch like the guy you paid for. www.mlb.com

Now circle ages 34 through 38. That’s five seasons at roughly $45 million apiece, or about $225 million at that rate. What are you counting on for those five years? Thirty starts? Twenty? And if he needs surgery at 35, how much can you reasonably expect from him at 36, 37 and 38? The checks clear either way.

Then there’s the Juan Soto math. Soto’s deal averages $51 million a year. Add Skubal and you’re at roughly $95 million a year in average contract value for two players. Skubal made 26 starts last season. He can own a Friday night at Citi Field, and I’d love to be there for it. Then somebody else has to get outs on Saturday, Sunday, Monday and Tuesday. An ace is worth even more in October. You still need a rotation, a bullpen and a lineup deep enough to get there. www.mlb.com

Make Skubal a monster offer for a shorter term. If nine years is what it takes, let somebody else spend the next decade checking the radar gun.

You’ve already bought the Mets a superstar. Now give him a team.

Let’s Go Mets,
Short Matt – A fan who remembers deGrom’s elbow just fine

That’s all I got today.

Share Button
About Matt McCarthy 424 Articles
Matt McCarthy, is the MTM founder and consequently wears many hats: Director, Editor, Writer, Web guy and Podcaster... Also known as Short Matt, he's also a two-bit actor, voice-over pro, rugby, baseball and ice hockey player and likes hazelnut coffee with rice milk, while strolling in the sand, listening to foreign films... Matt also moonlights on MTM spin-off, RugbyWrapUp.com, often wearing a wig and glasses while butchering a Kiwi accent.