NEW YORK, NY – As we head into the All-Star break of the 2025 MLB season, the playoff picture is starting to take shape—though not the way many predicted back in April. The Orioles are unraveling, the Dodgers are injured, and yes, Juan Soto is now a Met. Let’s break it all down, and build out the greatest All-Time All-Star lineups while we’re at it.
Who Will Win the World Series?
The Dodgers Are Winning… Sort Of
Despite leading the NL West at 56–39, the Dodgers are running on fumes. With Yoshinobu Yamamoto and Tyler Glasnow coming back from injuries, and Walker Buehler now pitching in Boston, their rotation looks more like a MAS*H unit than a playoff juggernaut.
Orioles, Meet Gravity
The once-promising Orioles have plummeted to 43–50, raising serious questions about depth, bullpen reliability, and how quickly things can fall apart when the baseball gods stop smiling.
AL and NL Favorites (For Now)
American League – Toronto Takes the Crown (So Far)
The Blue Jays are quietly dominating at 55–39, with a deep, balanced roster that’s firing on all cylinders. The Yankees (53–41) are hanging in the race, even with Gerrit Cole out for the season. No, Juan Soto isn’t helping—he’s busy lighting up Citi Field.
National League – Philly vs. Queens
The Phillies (54–40) are as gritty and consistent as ever. But it’s the Mets (54–41) making noise with Soto now anchoring the lineup. Can New York stay healthy enough—and Mets-y enough—to make a real run? Time will tell.
World Series Prediction: Blue Jays vs. Mets
It’s been decades since either team hoisted the trophy. Expect offense, drama, and possibly the most fun cross-border showdown since the 2016 NHL playoffs.
All-Time MLB All-Star Lineups
Let’s take a timeout to honor the greatest players in history. Here are the ultimate American and National League All-Star lineups, [begrudgingly] with Designated Hitters.
American League All-Time Lineup
1. Rickey Henderson (LF) – Stole bases and headlines.
2. Derek Jeter (SS) – Captain Clutch himself.
3. Babe Ruth (RF) – The original home run king.
4. Alex Rodriguez (3B) – Power, drama, stats.
5. Lou Gehrig (1B) – Iron Horse. Icon.
6. Rod Carew (2B) – Surgical with the bat.
7. Yogi Berra (C) – 10 rings and a million quotes.
8. Mickey Mantle (CF) – Switch-hitting legend.
9. Ted Williams (DH) – Greatest pure hitter ever.
Starting Pitcher: Randy Johnson – Intimidating doesn’t begin to cover it.
National League All-Time Lineup
1. Pete Rose (LF) – Hustle personified.
2. Honus Wagner (SS) – The OG shortstop goat.
3. Hank Aaron (RF) – All class, all-time leader.
4. Albert Pujols (1B) – MVP machine.
5. Mike Schmidt (3B) – Big power, big glove.
6. Willie Mays (CF) – Five-tool perfection.
7. Johnny Bench (C) – Arm like a cannon.
8. Jackie Robinson (2B) – Changed the game.
9. Barry Bonds (DH) – The bat was hot, the debates hotter.
Starting Pitcher: Sandy Koufax – A short career, but an immortal one.
Final Word
This year’s World Series could easily be Blue Jays vs. Mets, a cross-border clash of hungry franchises looking to make history. Whether it’s Juan Soto in Queens or Vladimir Guerrero Jr. crushing in Canada, this second half is shaping up to be one for the books.
And if you’re building your all-time dream team? Good luck pitching to a lineup that includes Ruth, Bonds, and Mays. The only safe play might be to walk everyone and pray for rain.
Like what you read? Share this post, drop your own all-time lineup in the comments, and stay tuned for our post-trade deadline update next month.
